New Study Helps Explain Autism Subtypes

A new study that identifies four different subtypes of autism affirms what many experts — and parents — have long observed: the developmental disorder varies significantly from person to person. Or as the saying goes, “If you’ve met one autistic person, you’ve met one autistic person.”
Paige Kalika, D.O., a pediatric neurologist with the University of Miami Health System, works closely with children who have autism. She says the variety of symptoms and genetic traits she finds in her patients can range from the relatively mild to the more pronounced.
“This is why it’s called Autism Spectrum Disorder,” Dr. Kalika says. “We’ve known for some time that an autism diagnosis can represent multiple conditions bundled together with a lot of different symptoms. There can be a vast difference from one end of the spectrum to another.”
She lauds the new study as “the first of its kind to distinguish the complex disorder and confirm what so many of us understand about diagnosing and treating these children.”
Like the study authors, she believes that more research will lead to additional distinct autism subtypes. This process will help develop and apply interventions ranging from behavioral and educational therapies to medications.
The study, published in Nature Genetics, identifies four clinically and biologically distinct subtypes of the condition. Researchers looked at 230 traits — including repetitive behaviors, developmental milestones, and social interactions — of more than 5,000 autistic children who participated in an extensive cohort study called SPARK, which tracks genetic and clinical presentations in questionnaires filled out by their parents. The data collected was then plugged into a computational model that arranged the children together on a cluster of traits.
Each of the four subgroups carries its own different clinical, genetic, and biological profiles:
1. Social and Behavioral Challenges
This is the largest subtype, comprising 37% of the participants studied. This group has higher rates of anxiety, depression and ADHD. These children also show higher levels of repetitive behaviors and difficulties with social communications, but these tend to be classified as “mild core autism traits.” Generally, they do not have noticeable developmental delays. The genetic variations of this cohort affect physical traits and behaviors that tend to become noticeable later in childhood.
2. Moderate Challenges
The second largest subgroup, making up 34 percent of study participants, didn’t have co-occurring psychiatric conditions such as depression and anxiety, and they tended to reach developmental milestones with their age group. They did exhibit core autism behaviors — repetitive behavior, sensory sensitivities, lack of social interest or intense interest, and challenges with conversation — but not as strongly as other groups.
3. Mixed ASD with Developmental Delay
Comprising 19% of study participants, this group didn’t exhibit anxiety, depression or disruptive behaviors, but they did have repetitive behaviors and social setting challenges. They also experienced delays in early developmental milestones. This subtype tends to have genetic variants that affect early brain development.
4. Broadly Affected
The smallest group of participants (10%) exhibited the most severe challenges in almost every category, including developmental delays, psychiatric conditions, repetitive behaviors, and social issues. This subtype also had the most “de novo” mutations. These kinds of mutations are not inherited from parents. Rather, they occur for the first time in a family and are caused by DNA replication errors or exposure to mutagens like radiation or chemical substances.